Atlantia A&S Criteria
Includes non-performance entries in any media not covered by other categories. Examples: bookbinding, basketweaving, etc. This set of criteria applies to finished items only; crafts involving only the preparation of materials for other uses (e.g. paintmaking, tanning, dyemaking) should be entered in Material Preparation. As generic criteria, this set reflects the standards used in all non-performance criteria.
Information also available as PDF.
DOCUMENTATION (0-30 points. SCORE 0-10 then MULTIPLY BY 3):
Must have at least “EZ Doc” information. More is acceptable, although one or two pages (not counting visuals and bibliography) should be more than enough. If your documentation is more than three pages for exceptionally detailed and in-depth work, you should provide an executive summary. The best documentation will cover what they did in period, what the creator did in the project, and why the difference (if any). It will explain any conscious compromises made, and provide footnotes, illustrations, and references, as well as any original research or experimentation as it applies to the project. Give score based on the following considerations:
- A minimum of: what it is, where is it from, when is it from, and references;
- Materials used in the project;
- Techniques and tools used during the process;
- Research (country, period of origin, typical characteristics, etc.), visual references (books, portraits, etc.) from reliable sources;
- Artistic design elements and appropriateness to each other and to item’s purpose or use in period.
AUTHENTICITY (0-20 points) [SCORE 0-10 and then DOUBLE THE SCORE]:
- 0: Totally out of period and clearly modern;
- 1-2: Generally period, with some obvious modern elements present;
- 3-4: Generally period but with obvious mixture of elements from different cultures or periods;
- 5-6: Overall period style and execution with minor inconsistencies;
- 7-8: Period design and execution with no inconsistencies; period materials or reasonable equivalents;
- 9-10: Special effort to achieve completely period product by use of period design, materials, tools, techniques, etc. (e.g., all hand-done with period techniques); special effort to make entirely authentic and appropriate.
COMPLEXITY (1-10 points):
Rank the ambition of the entry, not the workmanship, scale of 1-10 considering the following:
- Scope of endeavor (number of pieces, size of work in relation to amount of detail, etc.) ;
- Difficulty and variety of design elements attempted;
- Difficulty and variety of techniques attempted;
- Difficulty and variety of media, materials, and tools used;
- Extent of original work (in patterns, etc.).
WORKMANSHIP (3-30 points. SCORE 1-10 then MULTIPLY BY 3):
Rank the quality of execution and success of the entry, scale 1-10 considering the following:
- Choice of materials, tools, methods, and techniques;
- Technique execution: neatness, precision, handling of materials, etc.;
- Form/design: balance, aesthetics, motifs, proportion, etc.;
- Function: does it do what it should do and look as it should look?;
- Mastery of period style and technique;
- Personalization or special embellishment.
OVERALL IMPRESSION (1-10 points):
Evaluate the work as a whole, rating the complete effect and appeal beyond the mere technical proficiency. Consider how you react to the entry (intuitive response) and other items not previously addressed.